kheru2006 (kheru2006) wrote,

Assessment Systems: Exams don’t boost creativity

THE examination-oriented system, where students sit the Ujian Pencapain Sekolah Rendah, Penilain Menengah Rendah and Sijil Pelajaran Malaysia examinations in the 11 years of schooling, should be reviewed for the transformation of the education system.


The purpose of examinations should be to assess, evaluate and reform.

Public examinations are  the benchmark of the  education system by which  stakeholders can  assess  students’ aptitude and knowledge.

The  Year Six examinations consists of  standardised tests to gauge whether pupils are  qualified to enrol for  elite boarding and premier secondary schools.

The PMR examination  segregates  science students from  arts students for  Form Four.

The UPSR and PMR examinations are  outdated and redundant. The largely multiple choice format questions of both examinations are not a reliable and valid indicator to gauge the aptitudes, abilities and cognitive skills of students.

The shift towards a knowledge- based economy needs a reformation and a rethink of our attitude towards education and examinations.
The social, economic and learning needs of  society,   nation and students are ill-served by an overemphasis on rote learning, or learning by memorising. 

 Rote learning and the multiple- choice format questions result  in the regurgitation of facts and reduction in critical, creative and independent thinking.

The purpose of examinations is to assess, evaluate and reform.

Only a  minority of  bright students who score a string of As are selected and sent to elite schools. A majority of students who do not score high  grades in the examinations are promoted automatically to a higher standard.

No remedial or reform classes are conducted to help  students who fare poorly.
Primary school children should master the 3 Rs of reading, writing and arithmetic before they go to secondary school.

However, many move on to secondary school after their UPSR examination even though they are unable to read or write. No remedial classes are held for children in  secondary school.

They remain illiterate till they leave school in Form Five.

The news report, “3 boys have last laugh with UPSR pass” (NST, Nov 18), talked about  three boys, who were prevented from taking the UPSR examination  initially by their school as they were deemed “not clever” and for fear that they would bring down the overall school results in the UPSR examination , but they scored a pass.

Their UPSR results were 2Cs and 3Es, 4Es and 1D and 2Es and 3Ds. 

They will now continue to Form One but teachers teaching them will  not be in laughing mood.    

It is the same with the PMR examination.

After PMR, all students are promoted to Form Four, irrespective of their grades. A single pass enables the student to progress to Form Four.

The non-academically-inclined students create disciplinary problems for  teachers.

Indiscipline in schools is related to the exam-oriented system,  which emphasises on the academic inclination of  students.

The reason why students go to school and study is  to pass an examination.  Teachers teach lessons tailored more for students to excel in examinations.  

School examinations do not boost  creativity and innovation with  multiple-choice format questions.

Examinations also do not  encourage students to be  involved in sports and co-curricular activities.
A school-based assessment system — consisting of project work, observations, attendance, mini tests, quizzes and oral presentation,  which is labour saving, economical and more appropriate for schools — should be adopted in place of the UPSR and PMR examinations. 

By Samuel Yesuiah, Seremban, Negri Sembilan

Source: The NST Opnion Lettes to the Editor 13 December 2011
Tags: assessment, education, exam

  • Education is a learning curve

    TERTIARY level students, especially those in their final year, are a step away from graduation and have one foot in the working world. I must admit…

  • Online education must continue

    Learning sessions and approaches through educational television will be taken to provide students without access to the internet but access to…

  • Do academic understand ‘unwrapping standards’?

    Unwrapping standard is a simple strategy for teachers to identify the skills and content knowledge needed in a lesson to ensure students are able to…

  • Post a new comment


    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded 

    When you submit the form an invisible reCAPTCHA check will be performed.
    You must follow the Privacy Policy and Google Terms of use.